Going through immigration court proceedings is very difficult, and for most, profoundly frightening. If a judge refuses to grant cancellation of removal, all the work and preparation may end in tears. However, there is a way to appeal a removal order, and it is never a bad idea to use all one’s options before conceding defeat.
The Board of Immigration Appeals
If ordered removed by a district court, the next step is to appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA). The BIA is an arm of the Justice Department, and it hears appeals from immigration cases as well as cases between an official or arm of the Department of Homeland Security and an individual or business. It also affirms the status of those entitled to argue before it. BIA decisions are subject to judicial review in federal court, but the overwhelming majority of immigration decisions simply do not wind up there; the court usually determines there is no need for further review.
The BIA will either agree with, or oppose, the immigration judge’s order of removal. If the BIA does not think you are removable, it will either order a remand, meaning that your case will go back to the immigration judge for another look, or it will grant you relief under its own mandate. If the BIA agrees with the immigration judge that you are removable, the next step is to appeal to federal court.
Appealing a “Final Order”
28 U.S.C. §158, also known as the Hobbs Administrative Review Act, governs the appeal of final orders of removal and grants jurisdiction to the federal courts. An order becomes final when it meets one of six criteria laid out in 8 CFR (Code of Federal Regulations) 1241.1. The criteria are as follows:
-
When an appeal is dismissed by the BIA;
-
When the respondent (the non-citizen) waives the right to appeal to the BIA;
-
When the BIA appeal period expires and nothing has been filed;
-
If certified to the Board or the Attorney General, on the date of the subsequent decision ordering removal;
-
If you are ordered removed in absentia (while you are not present), upon immediate issuance of that order; or
-
If you are granted voluntary departure and do not take it, or if you outstay the period of voluntary departure.
An order from an immigration judge also counts as final if an appeal to the BIA is not certified. If any of these situations has occurred in your case, your order is final and you do have the right to appeal to the federal Circuit Courts of Appeals.
An important caveat to realize is that filing an appeal to the federal court does not automatically result in a stay of removal. In other words, it does not allow you to stay in the United States just because you have an appeal pending. The exception to this is if you are a resident of the Ninth or Second Circuits. Illinois falls within the Seventh Circuit, meaning that if you file an appeal, you must also file a motion for a stay of removal— without a stay in place, Immigration & Customs Enforcement is entitled to arrest and detain you. However, even if you are deported, the Court of Appeals will still hear your petition.
Contact An Immigration Attorney
If you need help understanding your options regarding your order of removal, the Chicago immigration attorneys at the Katz Law Office, Ltd. are here to help. We have several convenient Chicagoland locations, and a history of success. Contact us today.